You are here:  » Fact Sheets » Heat or Ice? Which to do : Fact Sheet

Sports Physio Bundaberg

If you require sports physio in the Wide Bay, Burnett Region including Bundaberg, Childers and Gin Gin feel free to call us on (07) 4153 1920 or send us an enquiry via our contact us page. For general information about when you should apply heat to an injury or when you should alternatively apply ice, please read the below article:

Heat or Ice? Which to do: Fact Sheet

Self management of aches and pains is an important aspect of any rehabilitation. The initial management of injury can have a huge impact in the length and quality of recovery. Whilst there are many different slogans or mantras regarding the best forms of management and pain relief, generally they can be whittled down to the use of either heat or ice.

So which one should you use? Firstly, we need to look at the benefits of heat and ice on the body so that the next time pain strikes, you know whether to head to the freezer or microwave.


Ice is most effectively used in the initial management of mechanical or forceful soft tissue injuries. Many people would have heard of the R.I.C.E (or R.I.C.E.R) regime. This stands for Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation and Referral (to Physio/Doctor). Ice, along with rest, compression and elevation is used to help decrease blood flow to the affected area, which in turn means swelling is decreased, reducing the effects of secondary damage and promoting a better recovery.

The diagram below is a comparison of the same injury treated with the R.I.C.E.R. regime and without. The top row of pictures show the effects of a soft tissue injury when the R.I.C.E.R. regime is not used. The bottom row of pictures show the effects of a soft tissue injury when the R.I.C.E.R. regime is used. The first diagram in the series shows a rupture in the soft tissue immediately following an injury. 24 hours later, when R.I.C.E.R. has not been used, there is a large amount of uncontrolled bleeding and swelling. However, in the bottom diagram, the application of rest, ice, compression and elevation has significantly reduced the amount of bleeding and swelling.

Picture courtesy of Dr. Barry Oakes, MB, BS, MD, F.A.S.M.F. Senior lecturer in the department of Anatomy, Monash Universtity, Victoria, Australia

The Problem with Scar Tissue:

When a muscle is torn you would expect that the body would repair the muscle and allow for full movement again. In reality this doesn't happen. The tear or rupture is repaired with scar tissue. As you can see with the final diagram on the right hand side, when the R.I.C.E.R. regime is used, the formation of scar tissue is limited.

Scar tissue is made from a very brittle, inflexible fibrous material. This fibrous material binds itself to the damaged soft tissue fibres in an effort to draw the damaged fibres back together. What results is a bulky mass of fibrous scar tissue completely surrounding the injury site. In some cases it's even possible to see and feel this bulky mass under the skin.

Scar tissue is never as strong as the tissue it replaces. It also has a tendency to contract and deform the surrounding tissues, so not only is the strength of the tissue diminished, but flexibility of the tissue is also compromised.


Heat is effectively used to help decrease the intensity of muscle spasm and tightness generally associated with more chronic long term injuries. The application of a heat pack (and to a lesser extent heat based gel creams) can improve blood flow and muscle fibre flexibility, decreasing tension and leading to an overall decrease in pain levels. Sufferers of chronic back and neck pain will often find the application of a heat pack allows for greater freedom of movement and decreased ache.

As mentioned before, ice is used to effectively manage swelling in an acute injury. For the first 72 hours the use of ice is very important; just as important is the avoidance of heat. As you now know heat helps to promote blood flow, and heat in the initial 72 hours will further increase bleeding and swelling. However, after these initial stages, heat can be used to effectively manage swelling and other symptoms.

Following acute soft tissue injuries, no matter how much ice used, you will generally notice a localised area of swelling around the damaged tissue. This swelling is generally a waste product resulting from the damage of the original injury. This swelling around an injured area hampers new fresh blood, full of important nutrients and oxygen, from flowing to the area.

The use of a heat pack on the swollen area can help increase the overall blood flow. This increased blood flow will help to remove the waste products with each cycle around the body – removing the swelling and improving the availability of fresh blood. Fresh blood brings with it fresh nutrients, improving the quality of rehabilitation and decreasing scar tissue formation.

So in the end, if it’s a new injury that has occurred in the past 3 days, you can never get enough ice to the area. Apply for 15-20 minutes every hour, as regularly as possible.

If the injury is more long term and generally has some associated stiffness, apply a heat pack to the area to provide short term management of your pain levels. If you have any doubt, give us a call. If you are still feeling pain after 2 days of ice or heat, you should come and see us.

To download the PDF of this article please click here.

Quay St PhysioWe pride ourselves on servicing the community, and with 7 Physiotherapists on staff, we endeavour to provide treatment in a timely manner.